Leeds Pharmacist Says Sector Is ‘On Life Support’
Why Read This
What Makes This Article Worth Your Time
Summary
What This Article Is About
Ashley Cohen, a Leeds pharmacist who established his practice in 2006, warns that England’s community pharmacy sector is on “life support” and approaching collapse without urgent government intervention before Christmas. When Cohen opened his pharmacies serving Seacroft and Halton, he focused on patient care as a pleasure. However, the last decade has seen government funding for community pharmacies reduced dramatically—the National Pharmacy Association (NPA) reports core funding has fallen 40% after adjusting for inflation since 2015/16. This decline has made every year progressively harder, with prescription dispensing now actually losing money. Cohen provides a stark example: blood pressure medication costing him £4.50 per patient prescription receives only £3 government reimbursement, a pattern repeated across many medications. Meanwhile, costs have soared—national living wage increases and employer National Insurance contributions must be absorbed.
The economic pressure has transformed Cohen from healthcare professional focused on illness prevention into someone constantly worrying whether he can pay bills in 30, 60, or 90 days, essentially “supplying drugs budget out of my own pocket to the government.” The NPA has backed a “work to rule” ballot, meaning many pharmacies across England, Wales, and Northern Ireland could cut opening hours unless funding increases are secured. Trainee pharmacist Roshni Landa, on placement since July 2024, worries whether she’ll find employment if pharmacies close. Patients like Katherine Sulley and retired nurse Beverley Grant recognize pharmacies as “extremely valuable,” particularly for retired people dependent on prescriptions and broader NHS support—Grant notes that without local pharmacies and amid difficult GP access, the healthcare impact would be vast. The Department of Health and Social Care acknowledged inheriting a “neglected” system and committed to working with pharmacists toward a “service fit for the future” as part of its 10 Year Health Plan shifting care from hospitals to communities.
Key Points
Main Takeaways
Funding Collapsed 40% Since 2015
Core government funding for community pharmacies has fallen 40% after inflation adjustment since 2015/16, transforming once-sustainable practices into struggling businesses.
Prescription Dispensing Loses Money
Government reimbursement no longer covers medication costs—blood pressure prescriptions cost pharmacies £4.50 but receive only £3 reimbursement, forcing pharmacists to subsidize drugs.
Rising Costs Squeeze Margins
National living wage increases and employer National Insurance contributions compound the crisis as pharmacies absorb rising operational costs without corresponding funding increases.
Work-to-Rule Ballot Threatens Hours
The National Pharmacy Association backs work-to-rule action—many pharmacies in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland could cut opening hours unless government agrees funding uplift.
Trainees Face Uncertain Careers
Newly graduated pharmacists like Roshni Landa worry about finding employment if widespread closures occur, questioning whether they can continue their chosen careers.
Patients and NHS Both Suffer
Retired people depend on local pharmacies for prescriptions, and closures would burden an already-strained NHS as patients struggle to access GPs for appointments.
Master Reading Comprehension
Practice with 365 curated articles and 2,400+ questions across 9 RC types.
Article Analysis
Breaking Down the Elements
Main Idea
Unsustainable Economics Threaten Collapse
Chronic underfunding creates economically impossible conditions for community pharmacies. Cohen’s metaphor—sector moving from “life support” toward “end-of-life care”—captures existential crisis. 40% inflation-adjusted funding decline since 2015/16, combined with rising costs and below-cost reimbursement (£4.50 medication cost versus £3 reimbursement), creates perfect storm. Transforms Cohen from healthcare provider focused on prevention into desperate businessman calculating bill payment. Broader implications extend beyond pharmacy survival to NHS function—without accessible pharmacies, patients burden overstretched GPs. Represents systemic failure where government policy depends on private businesses subsidizing public service.
Purpose
Urgently Pressure Government Action
Generates public awareness and political pressure for immediate funding. Cohen’s Christmas deadline creates temporal urgency. Multiple perspectives broaden impact: Cohen (owner/clinician), Landa (career anxieties), patients (community dependence, NHS interconnection). Retired nurse Grant’s 44-year career lends NHS support claims authority. Work-to-rule ballot signals pharmacies’ willingness reducing services, potentially galvanizing patient advocacy. Department response acknowledging neglect suggests reporting prompted official engagement. Frames crisis through relatable local example rather than abstract statistics, humanizing policy failure through real people facing consequences.
Structure
Personal → Data → Stakeholders → Official Response
Opens with Cohen’s journey from 2006 pleasure to current crisis—establishing emotional connection before numbers. NPA’s 40% funding decline grounds subjective experience in objective data. Cohen’s detailed economics provides concrete unsustainability evidence. Expands through Landa (career prospects) and patients (Sulley, Grant). Multi-stakeholder approach demonstrates crisis affects owners, emerging professionals, dependent populations. Work-to-rule ballot escalates urgency. Department response concluding acknowledges neglect while promising collaboration without concrete commitments. Moves from individual hardship through collective impact to political acknowledgment, building intervention case while documenting inadequate response.
Tone
Urgent, Concerned, Advocacy-Oriented
Balances professional journalism with clear pharmacy funding advocacy. Cohen’s dramatic metaphors create visceral urgency without sensationalism—clinical terms describing sector health literally. Contrast between past pleasure and present financial anxiety emphasizes tragic transformation. Treats pharmacy owners as healthcare professionals first, business owners second. Patient voices express genuine concern without hysteria. Landa’s career anxiety adds poignancy without melodrama. Department response receives neutral presentation—acknowledgment and commitment appear without editorial comment, letting vagueness speak itself. Measured urgency suits BBC’s public service mission: alarming enough demanding attention, credible enough maintaining authority.
Key Terms
Vocabulary from the Article
Click each card to reveal the definition
Build your vocabulary systematically
Each article in our course includes 8-12 vocabulary words with contextual usage.
Tough Words
Challenging Vocabulary
Tap each card to flip and see the definition
Having lost confidence, hope, or enthusiasm; dispirited and discouraged by difficult circumstances.
“Demoralised pharmacists face uncertain future.”
To take in and reduce the effect of something; in business, to accept and cover costs without passing them on.
“National living wage and employer National Insurance contributions which he is having to absorb.”
Illnesses or health problems, typically minor or chronic conditions requiring medical attention.
“All sorts of backgrounds with all sorts of ailments.”
Absolutely necessary or essential; critically important to the functioning or survival of something.
“Community pharmacy had a vital role to play.”
Failed to care for properly; suffering from lack of attention, investment, or maintenance over time.
“We inherited a system that has been neglected for too long.”
The edge or verge of something dangerous or significant; the point beyond which something will happen or change.
“The sector needs an urgent injection of cash as it is on the brink of collapse.”
Reading Comprehension
Test Your Understanding
5 questions covering different RC question types
1According to the National Pharmacy Association, core government funding for community pharmacies in England has fallen by 40% after adjusting for inflation since 2015/16.
2What specific example does Ashley Cohen provide to illustrate the reimbursement gap problem?
3Which sentence best captures how the funding crisis has transformed Ashley Cohen’s professional focus?
4Evaluate these statements about stakeholder perspectives in the article:
Trainee pharmacist Roshni Landa worries about finding employment if widespread pharmacy closures occur after graduating from university.
The National Pharmacy Association opposes the work-to-rule ballot and encourages pharmacies to maintain current opening hours regardless of funding levels.
Retired nurse Beverley Grant recognizes that pharmacy closures would impact not just patients needing prescriptions but also the broader NHS given difficulty accessing GP appointments.
Select True or False for all three statements, then click “Check Answers”
5What can we infer about the Department of Health and Social Care’s position based on their statement in the article?
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
‘Work to rule’ represents a form of industrial action where workers strictly adhere to minimum contractual requirements without providing additional services. For pharmacies, the National Pharmacy Association-backed ballot means participating pharmacies could reduce opening hours to only what their contracts mandate rather than the extended hours many currently offer for patient convenience. This action stops short of striking—pharmacies wouldn’t close entirely—but would limit accessibility by eliminating early mornings, late evenings, or weekend hours not contractually required. The strategy pressures government for funding increases while technically continuing service provision. The ballot requires pharmacist voting approval, and implementation would occur across England, Wales, and Northern Ireland if government doesn’t agree to funding uplift. This represents escalation from individual pharmacy closures to coordinated sector-wide action.
While the article doesn’t detail policy reasoning behind the 40% inflation-adjusted funding decline since 2015/16, it occurs within broader NHS austerity context. Government healthcare budgets faced intense pressure during this period, and community pharmacy funding likely suffered as politically easier target than hospital services or GP practices with stronger patient visibility. The Department of Health and Social Care’s acknowledgment they ‘inherited a system that has been neglected for too long’ suggests previous administrations deprioritized pharmacy funding. Additionally, policymakers may have miscalculated pharmacy economic resilience—assuming businesses could absorb cuts through efficiency gains without recognizing that reimbursement rates below medication costs creates mathematically impossible economics. The reference to shifting care ‘from hospital to the community’ in the 10 Year Health Plan suggests recognition that underfunded community pharmacies contradict broader NHS strategy requiring robust primary care infrastructure.
Cohen exemplifies systemic rather than individual problems—his experience opening pharmacies in 2006 with optimism about patient care, then watching decade-long deterioration as funding declined while costs rose, mirrors the sector-wide trajectory. His specific examples (blood pressure medication costing £4.50 receiving £3 reimbursement, absorbing national living wage increases and National Insurance contributions) represent universal challenges facing all community pharmacies regardless of ownership structure or location. The transformation from healthcare professional focused on illness prevention to businessman worried about 30/60/90-day bill payment illustrates how underfunding forces clinical mission subordination to financial survival. His Pharm-Assist chain’s multiple locations in working-class Leeds communities (Seacroft, Halton) serving diverse patient populations demonstrates the public health impact—these aren’t boutique pharmacies in affluent areas but essential community infrastructure. The article’s choice of Cohen thus personalizes abstract statistics while ensuring his specificity represents broader patterns.
Readlite provides curated articles with comprehensive analysis including summaries, key points, vocabulary building, and practice questions across 9 different RC question types. Our Ultimate Reading Course offers 365 articles with 2,400+ questions to systematically improve your reading comprehension skills.
This article is rated Intermediate level. While discussing healthcare economics and policy (government funding, reimbursement rates, National Insurance contributions), the BBC presents information through accessible narrative focusing on personal impact. The piece requires understanding basic business concepts (costs exceeding revenue creates losses, inflation adjusts purchasing power) and healthcare system structure (community pharmacies versus hospitals, prescription dispensing process). Technical vocabulary (dispensing, reimbursing, work to rule, overheads) appears with sufficient context for comprehension. The multi-stakeholder structure—owner, trainee, patients, government—requires tracking different perspectives without complex argumentation. Statistical claims (40% funding decline) are presented straightforwardly without requiring economic theory background. The urgency around Christmas deadline and ‘life support’ versus ‘end-of-life care’ metaphors provide dramatic framing making abstract policy tangible. Readers comfortable with news reporting about public services and basic economic literacy should find the content accessible despite substantive implications for UK healthcare delivery.
While the article focuses on prescription dispensing economics, retired nurse Beverley Grant’s observation reveals broader NHS support function: ‘If people haven’t got local pharmacies and it’s hard to get into GP practices for appointments it would have a big impact on the NHS.’ Community pharmacies serve as accessible primary care contact points for minor ailments, medication advice, health screening, and triage—services that would otherwise burden overstretched GP practices and emergency departments. Ashley Cohen describes wanting to ‘spend his time and energy in trying to prevent illness’—preventive services beyond mere prescription fulfillment. The Department of Health’s reference to ‘moving the focus of care from hospital to the community’ in the 10 Year Health Plan positions pharmacies as essential infrastructure for this shift. Pharmacy closures thus don’t merely inconvenience patients needing prescriptions—they eliminate accessible healthcare touchpoints, forcing people toward more expensive, less appropriate care settings when pharmacist consultation might have sufficed.
The Ultimate Reading Course covers 9 RC question types: Multiple Choice, True/False, Multi-Statement T/F, Text Highlight, Fill in the Blanks, Matching, Sequencing, Error Spotting, and Short Answer. This comprehensive coverage prepares you for any reading comprehension format you might encounter.
